A widely cited trial published in the BMJ in 2008 found that for couples with unexplained infertility, popular treatments such as clomiphene combined with insemination did not clearly improve the chance of a baby compared with simply waiting and trying naturally. The findings made many couples ask whether the infertility treatment they were offered was really successful, and whether stress is the real culprit. This page explains what the research does and does not mean, how clinics measure success, what the role of stress is, and how to choose a sensible plan.
Not sure which infertility treatment is right for you?
Share your reports and treatment so far, and our specialists will plan your personal homeopathic care, in person at our Mumbai clinics or online from anywhere. Your first consultation and assessment is free. Welling’s HART protocol can save up to 90% of the usual IVF cost, and help you conceive naturally.
Call +91 8080 850 950 for a 1:1 personal consultation with our experts today.
Treatment success and stress at a glance
- What the trial found: in unexplained infertility, mild stimulation with insemination added little over waiting and timed intercourse.
- But: for women who do not ovulate, ovulation-inducing drugs clearly help.
- Success figures: check whether a quoted rate is per cycle, per embryo transfer or cumulative, and whether it counts pregnancies or live births.
- Stress: infertility causes stress; there is little evidence that everyday stress alone causes infertility.
- Age: success depends heavily on the woman’s age, so decisions should be personal.
What the research found
The BMJ trial compared clomiphene with insemination, unstimulated insemination and expectant management in couples with unexplained infertility. There was no clear difference in live births. Later trials gave a more nuanced picture: stronger injectable stimulation with IUI gave more live births in one large US trial, but with a higher risk of multiple pregnancy. Some guidelines therefore advise against routine mild stimulation for unexplained infertility.
What this does and does not mean
- For women who do not ovulate, ovulation-inducing drugs clearly help
- For couples whose tests are normal, the added benefit of mild stimulation with insemination is small, especially for younger women
- Waiting and timed intercourse remain reasonable for a limited period when the woman is young
- For older women, delay carries a real cost, so decisions should be made with a specialist
How to read success rates
When a clinic quotes a success rate, ask exactly what it measures. The same treatment can look very different depending on the definition.
| Term | What it means | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Pregnancy rate | Positive pregnancy test or scan, not necessarily a baby | Higher than the live birth rate, because it includes miscarriages |
| Live birth rate | Babies born per cycle, per transfer or per couple | The outcome that matters most |
| Per cycle or per transfer | Result of a single attempt | Lower than the cumulative figure over several attempts |
| Cumulative rate | Result across several cycles in a defined period | Shows what is realistic over time |
| Age group | Rates reported for the woman’s age | A clinic’s overall rate hides large differences by age |
Age has a large effect: UK regulator reports show that the chance of a live birth per embryo transferred in IVF is roughly one in three for women under 35, one in four at 35 to 37, one in five at 38 to 39, about one in nine at 40 to 42 and about one in twenty beyond 42. Always compare like with like.
Is stress the culprit?
Infertility certainly causes stress, and stress can reduce libido and disturb ovulation in some women. There is little evidence, however, that everyday stress alone causes infertility, so couples should not blame themselves. Reducing stress through sleep, exercise, counselling and support helps wellbeing and makes a long treatment journey easier to bear. See our page on the psychological impact of infertility on couples.
Choosing a sensible plan
- Complete the basic investigations for both partners.
- Ask your doctor about the evidence for every proposed treatment, and what the chance of a live birth is for your age and diagnosis.
- Think about how long you can afford to try each option, given your age.
- Avoid costly add-ons with little proof.
- Look after your emotional health, and agree a plan together.
Homeopathic treatment is individualised and some couples choose to try it first or alongside other treatments. Please do not stop prescribed medicines without discussing it with your fertility doctor. Read more in homeopathy infertility treatment and why common fertility medicines do not always work.
Frequently asked questions about infertility treatment success
1. Is infertility treatment really successful?
It depends on the cause, the treatment and above all the woman’s age. Treatments such as ovulation induction in women who do not ovulate work well; mild stimulation with IUI adds little for couples with normal tests.
2. What was the BMJ trial about?
It compared clomiphene with insemination, unstimulated insemination and waiting in couples with unexplained infertility, and found no clear improvement in live births with the treatments.
3. Does stress cause infertility?
Everyday stress is not shown to cause infertility, although severe stress can disturb ovulation and libido. Infertility itself is very stressful, so supportive care matters.
4. How should I compare IVF success rates between clinics?
Compare live birth rates, not pregnancy rates, for your age group, and check whether the figure is per cycle, per transfer or cumulative. Be cautious about rates that exclude difficult cases.
5. Is it safe to wait and try naturally?
For a limited period, yes, in a young woman with normal tests. If you are over 35 or have been trying for a long time, do not delay assessment.
6. Should I try IVF straight away if my tests are normal?
Not necessarily. The choice depends on age, duration of infertility and your wishes. Ask your specialist about expectant management, IUI and IVF, and what each is likely to achieve.
7. Can homeopathy be tried first?
Some couples choose to try homeopathic treatment first or alongside other treatments. It should not delay assessment if the woman is over 35, and prescribed medicines should not be stopped without medical advice.
8. What questions should I ask my fertility doctor?
Ask about the diagnosis, the chance of a live birth per cycle for your age, risks such as multiple pregnancy, the cost, and what the next step is if the treatment does not work.
Related Reading
- Why Are the Most Commonly Prescribed Infertility Treatment Medicines Not Always Effective?
- What Is The Success Rate Of IVF? By Age, By Cycle and How To Improve It
- How Safe Is IVF? Risks, Side Effects, Long-Term Effects and a Natural Alternative
- Beyond IVF: What Are Best Natural Alternatives To IVF?
- Homeopathy Infertility Treatment: HART, a Proven Way to Conceive Naturally
- Infertility and Mental Health: The Psychological Impact on Couples and How to Cope
To consult Welling Homeopathy experts, call +91 80 80 850 950.
Disclaimer: this page is for information only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Results vary from person to person.